A $60 sale feels great, but it isn't $60 of profit. Between marketplace fees, payment processing, shipping, supplies, and what you paid for the item, the number you actually keep can be much smaller. Here's how to work it out properly.
The profit formula
Net profit = what the buyer paid − marketplace fees − payment processing fees − item cost − shipping you paid − supplies
Let's define each piece:
- What the buyer paid: the item price, plus any shipping the buyer paid you directly.
- Marketplace fees: the platform's commission or selling fee. It may be a percentage, a flat fee, or both, and some apply it to shipping too.
- Payment processing: on some marketplaces this is included in the main fee. On others it's charged separately.
- Item cost (COGS): what you paid for the item, including your share of any lot.
- Shipping you paid: the label cost, if you bought it. It's zero if the buyer's payment covered a prepaid label.
- Supplies: mailers, boxes, tape, and tissue. Small per item, but real.
Worked example
You sell a jacket for $48. You paid $9 for it at a thrift store. The buyer paid for the shipping label, and supplies cost about $0.50. In this example, the marketplace charges 12% and there's no separate payment fee.
| Buyer paid | $48.00 |
| Marketplace fee (example 12%) | −$5.76 |
| Item cost | −$9.00 |
| Supplies | −$0.50 |
| Net profit | $32.74 |
Try your own numbers in the resale profit calculator.
Margin vs. ROI: two different questions
Profit margin answers: of every dollar the buyer paid, how much did I keep?
Margin = net profit ÷ what the buyer paid × 100
In the example: $32.74 ÷ $48 = 68% margin.
Return on investment (ROI) answers: how hard did my money work?
ROI = net profit ÷ item cost × 100
In the example: $32.74 ÷ $9 = 364% ROI.
ROI is especially useful when sourcing, because it tells you which kinds of items and sources make your money grow fastest. Margin is useful for comparing marketplaces and pricing strategies.
Break-even price: the number to know before you list
Your break-even price is the lowest price at which you don't lose money. It matters most for low-cost items, where fixed fees and shipping can wipe out the profit.
Example: a book cost you $1, you pay a $5 shipping label, supplies are $0.30, and the (example) fee is 12% plus a $0.30 flat fee per order:
Break-even = (1.00 + 5.00 + 0.30 + 0.30) ÷ (1 − 0.12) = $7.50
Anything under $7.50 loses money. The profit calculator works this out for you.
Comparing marketplaces fairly
To compare where to sell an item, run the same item through the calculator with each marketplace's current fees and shipping setup. Look at:
- Net profit at a realistic price for that marketplace. Similar items often sell at different prices on different sites.
- How fast similar items sell there. A slightly lower profit that arrives this week can beat a higher one in three months.
- Who pays shipping, and whether the fee applies to shipping.
Profit mistakes to avoid
- Forgetting the item cost. "I sold $2,000 this month" means little without COGS.
- Ignoring small costs. Supplies, mileage, and returns add up across hundreds of sales.
- Using old fee numbers. Recheck fees whenever a marketplace announces changes.
- Not counting returns. A returned item can cost you shipping both ways.
Track it per item
The easiest way to know your real profit is to record cost, sale price, fees, and shipping for every item. The inventory template has these columns, and what to track in a reselling business covers the monthly numbers worth watching.
Swifty is being built for exactly this
We're building an inventory-first workspace for resellers. Join the early-access list for build updates. It's free, and there's no spam.
Join early access